Fred MacMurray is Jack Wright, a shopkeeper in the small town of Plainview, happily married and with a young son.
One day, a gang of outlaws ride into town and holds up the bank.
When the sheriff is shot, Jack grabs his pistol and picks off the outlaw carrying the loot.
He and fellow townsmen Al Ferguson, whose rifle shots also helped bring down the outlaw leader, are celebrated as heroes.
And talk of Jack’s heroic deed spreads, with the distance of his shot getting longer and longer with each telling.
Bob Dennis (Skip Homeier), brother of the outlaw MacMurray gunned down, isn’t humored. He’s in a vengeful mood.
He returns to Plainview and kills Ferguson. Everyone knows Jack is next on the outlaw’s list of potential victims.
Soon, the good folks of Plainview don’t want their kids hanging out with Jack’s son. Then they stop going to his store.
Finally, they offer to buy him out, if he’ll only leave town and free them from the threat of retaliation.
One of a number of serious Westerns MacMurray made in the 1950s before landing is Disney films and on TV in the hit series “My Three Sons.” It’s also one of the best.
In addition to a fine performance by MacMurray as the man who manages to keep his “heroic” deed in perspective, there’s the typical solid performance by Walter Brennan as the one townsman who stands by MacMurray, regardless of the situation.
Dorothy Malone is the shopkeeper’s wife; Tommy Retig, also starring on the TV show “Lassie” at the time, plays the son of Jack and Martha Wright.
Well done, and more violent than one would expect.
Directed by:
Albert Werker
Cast:
Fred MacMurray … Jack Wright
Dorothy Malone … Martha Wright
Walter Brennan … Doc Lacy
Tommy Retig … Billy Wright
John Qualen … Livingston
Irving Bacon … Al Ferguson
John Pickard … Alvin Dennis
Skip Homeier …. Bob Dennis
Whit Bissell … Clem Clark
Jack Lambert … Kirk
James Griffith … The Stranger
Runtime: 81 min.
Memorable lines:
Jack Wright, telling a stranger about how his good deed has been exagerated: “You’re looking at the man who shot the notorious Alvin Dennis from a distance of a half mile. With a slingshot.”
Town leader: “We need a marshal.”
Doc Lacy: “Well, hire one. Send to Abilene, Dodge City, one of those places. Get a gunman. Preferrably one with two guns … Or more.”
Bob Dennis: “We’re not leaving that town til that store keeper’s guts have been shot out.”