Dana Andrews is hard-working, no-nonsense Logan Stuart, a man determined to turn his freight line into a fortune in Oregon in the 1850s.
He has two problems, a friend named George Camrose (Brian Donlevy) with a weak spot for gambling that leads to bigger problems, and a cutthroat enemy named Honey Bragg (Ward Bond).
Women? Well, they complicate matters, too.
There’s Caroline Marsh, who wants Stuart and is also sought after by young farmer Vane Blazier. There’s Marta Lestrade, who keeps fending off the advances of Camrose.
And there’s flame-haired Lucy Overmire, who’s planning to marry Camrose, but wonders if he’ll ever measure up to Logan Stuart.
Lots of familiar faces show up in this slow-moving film with tons of subplots, that muddy the focus. And we never do find out why business-minded Logan Stuart feels so much allegiance to George Camrose, who shows up at, but can’t even be bothered to help with the work at a cabin raising.
Famed songwriter Hoagy Charmichael appears in one of his largest film roles and sings one of the songs he’s best known for — “Ole Buttermilk Sky.” And Ward Bond plays one of his least flattering characters, a man who kills for the pleasure of killing.
It’s his assault on an Indian girl that sets the “red beasties” — hey, that’s what they’re called in the film — on the warpath and leads to the film’s climax.
The familiar faces also include Andy Devine, whose real life son Tad played one of his sons in the film.
Directed by:
Jacques Tourneur
Cast:
Dana Andrews … Logan Stuart
Brian Donlevy … George Camrose
Susan Hayward … Lucy Overmire
Patricia Roc … Caroline March
Ward Bond … Honey Bragg
Hoagy Carmichael … Hi Linnet
Fay Holden … Mrs. Overmire
Stanley Ridges … Jonas Overmire
Lloyd Bridges … Johnny Steele
Andy Devine … Ben Dance
Victor Cutler … Vane Blazier
Rose Hobart … Marta Lestrade
Runtime: 93 min.
Memorable lines:
Logan Stuart: “Gold is only yellow gravel, Cornelius.”
Cornelius: “But the yellow color makes all the difference.”
Stuart: “Butter’s yellow too, and you can spread it on bread. Ever try that with gold.”
Cornelius: “For a businessman, you’ve got odd ideas.”
Ben Dance to Stuart: “You can’t tell them Army fellas nothin’. They got a little brown book. And if it ain’t in that little brown book, it just ain’t true.”
George Camrose, about his gambling problem: “I always feel lucky. That’s my trouble.”