Audie Murphy is Clay O’Mara, a railroad engineer who leaves Colorado and heads to the town of Santiago after learning his father and brother have been killed.
He goes to the local sheriff, hoping for a deputy’s badge to help his solve the mystery surrounding their deaths.
The sheriff gives him a badge, at the urging of a local attorney named Meredith, and sets him on the trail of Whitey Kincaid (Dan Duryea), a dangerous outlaw.
What O’Mara doesn’t know is that the sheriff and lawyer were behind the slayings and rustled his father’s cattle. They’ve sent him out to bring in Kincaid figuring he’ll be killed trying to accomplish the mission.
But things don’t work out quite like they planned.
In fact, O’Mara and Kincaid become friends of sorts. And diverting O’Mara from the mission of finding the real killers isn’t an easy chore.
Susan Cabot plays Laurie Kenyon, the woman who falls for Murphy. To complicate matters, she’s the niece of the sheriff, the man who keeps sending Clay on supposed suicide missions. And the former fiancee of Meredith.
One of the more entertaining Audie Murphy vehicles. Outlaw Whitey Kincaid keeps hinting at the truth about the sheriff of Santiago. Murphy’s Clay O’Mara keeps thinking he’s joking.
As usual, Duryea provides a nice touch as the slightly maniacal outlaw, torn between watching Murphy wriggle out of tough spots and lending a hand.
Russell Johnson of future Gilligan’s Island fame plays Jed Ringer, an often drunk henchman who does dirty work for Sheriff Kenyon and Meredith. Abbe Lane plays his barroom singer girlfriend, who was once romantically involved with Whitey.
After several twists and turns, Clay realizes Whitey has been serious about the sheriff being crooked, leading to a well-down final showdown.
Directed by:
Jesse Hibbs
Cast:
Audie Murphy … Clay O’Mara
Susan Cabot … Laurie Kenyon
Dan Duryea … Whitey Kincaid
Abbe Lane … Kate
Russell Johnson … Jed Ringer
Paul Birch … Sheriff Kenyon
William Pullen … Tom Meredith
Jack Elam … Tim Lowerie
Denver Pyle … Rev. Moorehead
Hamilton Camp … Andrew O’Mara
Tim Graham … Patrick O’Mara
Runtime: 81 min.
Memorable lines:
Tim Lowerie: “Strangers don’t ask questions in Diablo. They just answer them.”
Whitey Kincaid: “Kenyon’s gonna be the most surprised man in the county if you bring me in.”
Clay O’Mara: “When I bring you in.”
Whitey: “Well, you got a right to your own opinion.”
Clay O’Mara: “Here’s your gun.”
Whitey Kincaid: “It’s loaded.”
Clay: “Wouldn’t do you much good empty.”
Whitey: “Listen, kid, you’re talkin’ to Whitey Kincaid. Nobody hands me loaded guns. I shoot people in the back … How did you ever manage to live this long?”