Fate brings three small-time thieves together in 1876 Texas.
Tanner Beard plays James McKinnon, who arrives in Dallas with his pockets full of stolen cash and a watch handled down by his family in Ireland.
By the time saloon gal Katherine Prescott gets through with him, only the watch remains.
Eric Balour plays Will Edwards, a member of the James-Younger gang, hired to get revenge against a guy named “Champagne” Charlie Austin.
When a barroom encounter leads to gunfire, he wants no part of the killing. So he and McKinnon swipe a stage and head to Granbury, where the friend who’s supposed to help them has just gotten shot over a bowling wager.
So they turn to Kelly (Lou Taylor Pucci), an errand boy for town boss J.H. Gordon. And they all wind up on the run together after he steals a derringer supposedly used to kill Lincoln and a posse shows up.
Now they’re on the run with stolen hides, a stolen gun and no horses. The owner of the hides is on their trail. So is the owner of a boat in which they made their getaway.
Not to mention the posse. And the Comanches who live in the area.
![Tanner Beard as James McKinnon, who finds himself robbed, hunted by the law and stranded with an outlaw he doesn't know in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Tanner-Beard-as-James-McKinnon-who-finds-himself-robbed-hunted-by-the-law-and-stranded-with-an-outlaw-he-doesnt-know-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Tanner Beard as James McKinnon, who finds himself robbed, hunted by the law and stranded with an outlaw he doesn’t know in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
It takes a while to get going with characters appearing and disappearing in a flash before the film’s focus settles in on James, Will and Kelly.
But even before the focus becomes clear, the acting and direction is a notch above what we’ve come to expect from 21st Century Westerns.
Not everything works. The shootout over a game of bowling is ludicrous.
But more works than doesn’t and we get solid performances from several supporting members of the cast, including Jenna DeWan-Tatum as Katherine, Henry Thomas as John St. Helens (the man who claims he’s really John Wilkes Booth) and Jamie Thomas King as Doc Holliday.
![Lou Taylor Pucci as Kelly, the man who winds up with John Wilkes Booth's pistol in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Lou-Taylor-Pucci-as-Kelly-the-man-who-winds-up-with-John-Wilkes-Booths-pistol-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Lou Taylor Pucci as Kelly, the man who winds up with John Wilkes Booth’s pistol in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
![Henry Thomas as John St. Helens, the man who says he's really John Wilkes Booth in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Henry-Thomas-as-John-St.-Helens-the-man-who-says-hes-really-John-Wilkes-Booth-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Henry Thomas as John St. Helens, the man who says he’s really John Wilkes Booth in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
Directed by:
Tanner Beard
Cast:
Eric Balour … Will Edwards
Tanner Beard … James McKinnon
Lou Taylor Pucci … Kelly
Henry Thomas … John St. Helens
Jeanna DeWan-Tatum … Katherine Prescott
Summer Glau … Maggie Moon
Kevin Alejandro … August Edwards
Jamie Thomas King … John Henry Doc Holliday
Drew Waters … Champagne Charlie Austin
Jim Beaver … J. Wright Mooar
Glenn Morshower … J.H. Gordon
Runtime: 108 min.
![Jeanna DeWan-Tatum as Katherine Prescott, the whore who steals James' heart and money in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Jeanna-DeWan-Tatum-as-Katherine-Prescott-the-whore-who-steals-James-heart-and-money-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Jeanna DeWan-Tatum as Katherine Prescott, the whore who steals James’ heart and money in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
![Summer Glau as Maggie Moon with her father after bandits have hit their home in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Summer-Glau-as-Maggie-Moon-with-her-father-after-bandits-have-hit-their-home-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Summer Glau as Maggie Moon with her father after bandits have hit their home in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
Memorable lines:
James: “Indians are sneaky. I should stay behind in case they start killing people.”
Holliday, offering James a drink: “The fires of hell mixed with the waters of heaven.”
Holliday to Charlie Austin: “You couldn’t shoot your hand if you put your finger in the barrel.”
Will, bending over to pick an arrowhead out of the water: “Look what I found.”
Kelly, acting frantic: “Put that back. They say it’s bad luck to find an arrowhead in a creek.”
Will tosses the arrowhead down quickly, clearly afraid of bringing on bad luck.
Kelly: “Just funning, ya, Irish.”
![Jamie Thomas King as Doc Holliday, the dentist who pulls James' aching tooth in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Jamie-Thomas-King-as-Doc-Holliday-the-dentist-who-pulls-James-aching-tooth-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Jamie Thomas King as Doc Holliday, the dentist who pulls James’ aching tooth in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
![Glenn Morshower as J.H. Gordon, angered that someone has died on his property in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Glenn-Morshower-as-J.H.-Gordon-angered-that-someone-has-died-on-his-property-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Glenn Morshower as J.H. Gordon, angered that someone has died on his property in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
![The tracker whose boat and whiskey the three young men steal in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/The-tracker-whose-boat-and-whiskey-the-three-young-men-steal-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
The tracker whose boat and whiskey the three young men steal in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011). Does anyone know who plays this part?
![William McNamara as Jones Moon, looking for the men who robbed his homestead in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/William-McNamara-as-Jones-Moon-looking-for-the-men-who-robbed-his-homestead-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
William McNamara as Jones Moon, looking for the men who robbed his homestead in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
![Summer Glau as Maggie Moon, admiring a pretty dress her pa can't afford in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Summer-Glau-as-Maggie-Moon-admiring-a-pretty-dress-her-pa-cant-afford-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Summer Glau as Maggie Moon, admiring a pretty dress her pa can’t afford in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
![Jeanna DeWann-Tatum as the pretty whore Katherine Prescott who turns James head in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Jeanna-DeWann-Tatum-as-the-pretty-whore-Katherine-Prescott-who-turns-James-head-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Jeanna DeWann-Tatum as the pretty whore Katherine Prescott who turns James head in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)
![Tanner Beard as James McKinnon, Lou Taylor Pucci as Kelly and Eric Balour as Will Edwards, spooked by a noise in the brush in The Legend of Hell's Gate (2011)](https://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Tanner-Beard-as-James-McKinnon-Lou-Taylor-Pucci-as-Kelly-and-Eric-Balour-as-Will-Edwards-spooked-by-a-noise-in-the-brush-in-The-Legend-of-Hells-Gate-2011.jpg)
Tanner Beard as James McKinnon, Lou Taylor Pucci as Kelly and Eric Balour as Will Edwards, spooked by a noise in the brush in The Legend of Hell’s Gate (2011)